THE FULL ASK:
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
40 Garden Place
In Contract · Brooklyn Heights

40 Garden Place

$12,750,000
Inquire
Beds:
5
Baths:
3
Taxes:
$2,533/mo
Type:
Single-family
Building:
Greek Revival single-family (c.1848) within the Brooklyn Heights Historic District, the first designated in New York.
Listed by:
Callie Katt, Compass
Photography:
Compass
Featured on @thefullask

40 Garden Place is a gut-renovated single-family house on one of Brooklyn Heights' quietest lanes, in contract at $12,750,000. Garden Place earned its name honestly: the street was laid out in 1842 across the formal garden behind the mansion of Philip Livingston, a New York signer of the Declaration of Independence, and parts of the old garden wall still stand as back fences on the block today.

40 Garden Place — photo 1

The house is a mid-19th-century Greek Revival brought forward, five bedrooms across twelve rooms, inside the first historic district New York ever designated, in 1965. The renovation reads as English cottage warmth meeting Scandinavian restraint, most of all in the steel-framed rear that opens to the garden.

40 Garden Place — photo 2
40 Garden Place — photo 3
40 Garden Place — photo 4
40 Garden Place — photo 5
40 Garden Place — photo 6
40 Garden Place — photo 7
40 Garden Place — photo 8

Frequently asked

Where is 40 Garden Place?
40 Garden Place is located in Brooklyn Heights, New York.
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 40 Garden Place have?
40 Garden Place has 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms.
How much is 40 Garden Place?
40 Garden Place was last asking $12,750,000.
What are the monthly carrying costs at 40 Garden Place?
40 Garden Place carries property taxes of $2,533 per month.
Who is the listing agent for 40 Garden Place?
40 Garden Place is listed by Callie Katt, Compass.

If you would like to feature your property on The Full Ask, please visit our submissions page. Featured properties are introduced to our community of agents, designers, and buyers who care about well-considered real estate.

Inquire
Are you working with an agent?

Your inquiry goes straight to the listing representative, Callie Katt.

You might also like:
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
78 Windmill Lane
$65,000–$70,000/season
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
601 Madison Street
$2,800,000
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
500 West 21st Street #GF
$49,500/mo
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
10 East 14th Street #PH
$41,000/mo

Be the first to access featured listings

© 2026 The Full Ask LLC. All rights reserved.