THE FULL ASK:
543 Manhattan Avenue
543 Manhattan Avenue
543 Manhattan Avenue
543 Manhattan Avenue
543 Manhattan Avenue
543 Manhattan Avenue
543 Manhattan Avenue
543 Manhattan Avenue
543 Manhattan Avenue
543 Manhattan Avenue
For Sale · Harlem

543 Manhattan Avenue

$2,350,000
Inquire
Beds:
5
Baths:
4
Sq Ft:
3,420
Type:
Two-family rowhouse
Built:
1901
Building:
A 1901 two-family rowhouse on the Harlem edge of Morningside Park, from the last building wave before the IRT reached Morningside Heights in 1904.
Listed by:
Christina Prostano, Global Collective Team
Featured on @thefullask
The Story

The tax rolls put 543 Manhattan Avenue at 1901, and the date matters: it went up in the last quiet stretch before the IRT reached Morningside Heights in 1904 and touched off the speculative rowhouse boom that filled the side streets. This is one of the earlier houses, on the Harlem edge of Morningside Park.

543 Manhattan Avenue — photo 1

Inside it reads more like a loft than a rowhouse: exposed brick and beamed ceilings run floor to floor, a grand piano anchors the parlor, fireplaces repeat upstairs, and a planted garden sits behind. Five bedrooms, four baths, 3,420 square feet across a two-family layout.

543 Manhattan Avenue — photo 2
543 Manhattan Avenue — photo 3
543 Manhattan Avenue — photo 4
543 Manhattan Avenue — photo 5
543 Manhattan Avenue — photo 6
543 Manhattan Avenue — photo 7
543 Manhattan Avenue — photo 8

Frequently asked

Where is 543 Manhattan Avenue?
543 Manhattan Avenue is located in Harlem, New York.
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 543 Manhattan Avenue have?
543 Manhattan Avenue has 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms.
How big is 543 Manhattan Avenue?
543 Manhattan Avenue measures approximately 3,420 square feet.
When was 543 Manhattan Avenue built?
543 Manhattan Avenue is a two-family rowhouse built in 1901.
How much is 543 Manhattan Avenue?
543 Manhattan Avenue is asking $2,350,000.
Who is the listing agent for 543 Manhattan Avenue?
543 Manhattan Avenue is listed by Christina Prostano, Global Collective Team.

If you would like to feature your property on The Full Ask, please visit our submissions page. Featured properties are introduced to our community of agents, designers, and buyers who care about well-considered real estate.

Inquire
Are you working with an agent?

Your inquiry goes straight to the listing representative, Christina Prostano, Global Collective Team.

You might also like:
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
15 Back Shandelee Road
$975,000
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
Ohayo Mountain House, Woodstock
$1,975,000
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
123 Willoughby Avenue
$7,495,000
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
7 Hubert Street #10A
$8,500,000

Be the first to access featured listings

© 2026 The Full Ask LLC. All rights reserved.Operated by Robert Goldstein.